Stupid Security
News Humor Howlers
search Stupid Security:
 
Exposing Fake Security Since 2003
 
Stupid Security
- About
- FAQ
- RSS
- Discussions
- Journals
- Messages
- Topics
- Authors

- Preferences
- Older Stuff
- Past Polls
- Submit Story

Stupid Security
Portions of Stupid Security are copyright 2003 by Nat Howard and his licensors.

 
Fancy new screening machine; same dumb TSA
posted by nrh on Monday February 13, @09:49AM
Howlers Holden McCrank writes "Recently, I flew out of the Gulfport, MS airport. They've installed one of those new passenger screening machines that blows puffs of air across a person, then sucks them into a mass spectrometer to test for explosives. At least that's the idea. I talked to the manufacturer of one of these devices at a trade show, and he admitted that one of the classic "false positive modes" for the device was little old ladies and their glycerine-based lotions (apparently a false positive for nitroglycerine).

So here's the sequence of events I encountered going through screening:

1) I take off my shoes and put them in a bucket to go through the Xray, along with my backpack, coat, and laptop. The TSA goon informs me I don't need to do that. I put them back on.

2) I await entry to the "blower." Two folks in front of me is a little old lady (LOL). Puff, puff, puff, and there's a long pause. The doors don't open to allow her to exit. Meanwhile my laptop has already gone through the Xray and is sitting forelornly all by itself at the end of the conveyor, just waiting for someone to snatch it.

3) Another TSA goon hauls the LOL out of the machine, and another begins wiping the inside down with a pad. I, and the other folks in front of me, are then directed to bypass the scanner.

4) Yet another TSA goon tells me to remove my shoes. Dammit.

5) Pass through the metal detector, then go to see if my laptop's still there (it is) and await my shoes.

6) As I depart the screening area, the LOL is sitting in a chair, and a TSA goon is talking to her. I hear little bits of conversation, including "with the back of my hand" and "sensitive areas" and "right to a private room."

Way to go, TSA! You got to feel up a little old lady, while the rest of us potential miscreants got to bypass your detector for free."

Thanks, Holden -- the picture of lots of little old ladies being searched would be, I think, the kind of visual nightmare that may sink this program. What's next? Perhaps machines that give false positives when apple pie or baseball cards go through the machine?

No Canadian Techies Allowed | But Who Protects Us From The Air Marshals?  >

 

 
Stupid Security Login
Nickname:

Password:

[ Create a new account ]

Related Links
  • More on Howlers
  • Also by nrh
  • Fancy new screening machine; same dumb TSA | Login/Create an Account | Top | 8 comments | Search Discussion
    Threshold:
    The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
    Old people with heart problems and condoms?? (Score:1)
    by cef on Monday February 13, @07:05PM (#1240)
    User #415 Info
    Nitroglycerin is a common medicine available as a tablet and dermal patch, but is also available in spray and ointment forms. The ointment gives of a very strong smell after a while, and the spray of course could be a problem by itself. Does this mean old poeple have to register themselves as a potential "threat"?

    And on top of all this, apparently there's a condom on the market that contains a small amount of Nitroglycerin in the tip, to promote an erection. Unfortunately, I think it'll be lost on the officer performing the cavity search though.
    [ Reply to This | Parent ]
    should be lots of false positives (Score:1)
    by computer spook on Tuesday February 14, @09:56AM (#1242)
    User #260 Info
    Given the small amounts of explosive and other materials we want to find, and given the number of uses that we put tp these materials I would expect that these machines should produce a large number of false positives. Certainly there are people who work with explosives as explosives for legit reasons. Such as an aquaintance of mine who works for the federal government repairing computer controls for making devices to mount on places and drop on the enemy. He tested positive for traces of explosives. By the way don't don't don't say what he did in explination "I should test positive after all I make bombs for the same people how pay you salary (to a TSA agent)"

    But there are also others who probably don't even realize they should test positive. We have the obvious situation mentioned here were people are taking very small amounts of explosives as medications. We also have people who work in meat processing facilities. Truck mechanics, farmers, gardeners, janitors, need I go on.

    so I do wonder how useful these machines are going to be without a properly trained staff who knows what they do, how they do it, and what a positive of various kinds means. Hopefully at least the machine gives an indication of what compounds if "suspects" are in play.

    [ Reply to This | Parent ]
    9/11 commission report (Score:0)
    by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday February 15, @12:48PM (#1243)
    The first 20 pages of the 9/11 commission report are a horror story of simple security botched by untrained and incompetent staff. Despite triggering special inspections of their luggage, half of the people hijacking the planes were waved through without any body searches. The result was that they were all able to take daggers and box cutters on board.

    It sounds like nothing has changed. Despite spending billions on technology the simple stuff like good training and simple searches are still beyond the rent-a-cops.

    [ Reply to This | Parent ]
    nice (Score:1)
    by nj1631 on Monday December 17, @12:43AM (#2293)
    User #548 Info
    buy lace front wigs [rpgshow.com] cheap wigs [rpgshow.com] wigs pearl necklace [wal-land.com] necklace cheap wigs [rpgshow.com] buy costume wigs [rpgshow.com] wigs buy runescape money [r2shopping.com] cheap runescape gold [r2shopping.com] gold runescape gold [vponsale.com] money runescape [vponsale.com] gold
    [ Reply to This | Parent ]

    For a good time, call (510) 642-9483

    [ home | contribute story | older articles | past polls | faq | authors | preferences ]